Wednesday, January 29, 2014

Window Shopping

Yup,  I went window shopping last Sunday. Came home with four windows, four doors, a windshield, and a hatch.

That wasn’t the plan. I didn’t think I was taking delivery of a 2014 Volt until late next week, perhaps later or not at all if negotiations failed. I was working all of last week with one of the big-volume dealers in the Valley, mostly by phone and text, after visiting them on MLK day to check out the fully loaded Volt in their showroom. The exact car I wanted was in transit – a Summit White Volt with a black leather interior. I had a firm idea of what I wanted to pay for a 3-year/10,000 mile lease: $270/month plus tax, $0 drive-off. When the salesman called back with a $301/month + tax offer, I let him know that I was expecting a lower payment based on my calculations using the $3000-under-invoice offer that the dealer advertised on the Volt forum. I  wanted to pay no more than $300 including tax, so their offer was more than $1000 higher than what I was willing to cough up over the next three years. I asked if he could give me the details of the lease – specifically the gross capitalized cost, since that represents the sales price, and the capitalized cost reduction – but I didn’t get a call or text message with the information. After a couple of hours I got tired of waiting.

Coincidentally, the other big dealer in the Valley posted an ad on the same Volt forum. Their posting parroted the Volt lease terms that headlined their weekly sales ad in the local papers, delightfully complemented with a long list of the numerous Volts they had on the lot and in transit. I noticed that they too had the white-with-leather Volt of my dreams coming their way. I emailed the internet manager of that dealer with the lease terms offered by their competitor on the other side of the freeway. After a couple of email exchanges and a phone call from her salesman, they quoted $302/month, a buck more than the first dealer… but theirs also had the $525 safety package that includes a backup camera, which would be nice to have, but frankly I didn’t want to pay for it. After all,  that feature came standard on my Focus Electric, my wife’s Honda Pilot EXL, and her Sienna LE before that, so it just seemed wrong to have it as an option nowadays. I was really close to caving in and taking the deal anyway; fortunately I refrained and told the salesperson that I wanted to sleep on it and that I’d call him in the morning.

When I woke up the next morning, my intent was to head down to the Valley to try to negotiate a better deal in person with one or both dealers. Failing that, I would give up on getting a Volt for now and call Dianne at Carson Toyota about a RAV4 EV.  I figured that if I had to blow my budget, I’d blow it big-time on a Tesla drivetrain and lots of cargo space.

While I was getting ready to leave for the Valley, a salesperson from the local dealer called… which greatly annoyed me because I was in a rush to leave. I started chewing him out for not calling me when I first reached out to them last week, then went on and on about the deal I was trying to close that morning with one of the big Valley dealers, and then declared that there’s no way he can beat their deal because he doesn’t have any with Volts with leather only; all he had were fully optioned ones that were close to $40K. He asked if I would like a white one with a black cloth interior. I told him absolutely not, and ranted even more about how he simply does not have one in stock that I want.  I continued by telling him that if I can’t get the lease terms I want from one of the Valley dealers, I’m done with looking for a Volt anyway and will be going for a RAV4 EV. I was on a roll. He tried to interject, but I kept cutting him off.

Then, with one very sincere, personal apology, he calmed me down. As soon as he got my attention, He enthusiastically asked me if I had ever seen one with cloth, and that it actually looks great in black.  Then he asked me if I’ve driven the Volt yet. I paused for a second, then realized how unreasonably I was acting, because I certainly had done neither. He urged me to come to the dealership to see it, drive it, and give him a chance to beat the offers I had in hand. So I told him that I do qualify for the competitive lease rebate and GM employee discount, and promised that I’d hold off going down to the Valley for a half hour to let him work his offer.

Meanwhile, I called back the Valley dealer that has the safety package Volt, let the salesman know that I will drive down there immediately if he can close on $270/month + tax. He said he’ll have his manager call me.

Minutes later, the salesman from the local dealer called back and did the unexpected… he offered $269/month for 35 months, $0 due at signing. Including tax. That’s $247/month before tax. I was stoked – that was more than $50/month below the other two offers! I told him that I was impressed, and that I’d call him back before noon with a decision. I braced myself for a barrage of high-pressure tactics to force an immediate decision, but instead was left with a message of hope and opportunity. He thanked me for giving him a chance, said he’d be there for the day.

In short order, a manager from the Valley dealer called back. I told him about the local dealer’s offer on a base model, then rationalized that the MSRP of his incoming Volt with leather and backup camera was about 6% higher than for a base model, and that my $270/month  + tax my for his car was over 10% higher per month than what the local dealer quoted on a base model, so therefore my counter-offer was reasonable. The manager explained that the pricing structure is different for the cars with options, and that essentially their first and only offer of $302/mo plus tax is their final offer. I thought about it for a second, then decided I didn’t want to shell out and extra $50/month for the privilege of sitting on a dead cow every time I climbed into the Volt. I thanked him for his time and hung up.

I called the local dealer and said I have 30 minutes to spend with them before I needed to go back home and take care of some things. The salesman had the car waiting for me before I arrived, just outside the tall glass walls of the dealership. I was sold as soon as I laid eyes on it, but figured I’d better check out the cloth interior and drive it for a few blocks before inking a deal. So we took it for a spin…. The cloth looked and felt just fine, and in Sport mode  the Volt moved with the spunkiness of the Focus Electric. Fifteen minutes later we were back in the dealership to start the paperwork.

There’s only so much paperwork that can be done in fifteen minutes, but I really had to leave and couldn’t come back until about 5pm. The salesman handed me the keys to the Volt and had me sign a no-cost loaner agreement, said he needed me to take the Volt so that someone else couldn’t snag it from under me. Naturally, I obliged. When I returned later that day, I was taken straight to the finance office, and in 10 minutes the Volt was mine. In the end, the deal came out to be $267/month for 35 months, $0 at signing.

My local Chevy dealer really came through for me on this. Besides providing me with a great lease, they saved me from three 40-mile round-trip excursions into the Valley to work the deal, pick up the new Volt when it arrives, and then retrieve whichever car I took to the dealership to pick up the Volt. They treated me with courtesy, respect and efficiency, even after I started off on the wrong foot by chewing them out over the phone for taking so long to get back to me after I initially contacted them.
In retrospect, I do feel really bad about flying off the handle… especially today, after I sifted though unheard voice mail on my cell phone. Turns out that a manager from my local dealership had called me right after I reached out to them through edmunds.com; I just missed the call and didn’t bother to check voice mail.

Now it’s my turn to deliver a sincere, personal apology.

Sunday, January 19, 2014

Change of Heart

Dang, I must be getting old. It’s only been a few weeks, and I’ve already forgotten how to operate this newfangled electronical contraption.

My Focus Electric has been parked since the weekend before Christmas. Didn’t need to drive to work until after the New Year since the company shuts down the site for the holidays. And since traffic on the 405 was very light for the first couple of weeks in January, the benefit of using the HOV lane was diminished. Thus, I drove an ICE to work every day for the first seven work days of 2014 in an attempt to save a few bucks at lease termination – the Focus odo is already at 16000 miles after only 11 months. Combine that with a gross miscalculation on my part at a Ford dealership last February that resulted in my signing up for a 12000 mile/year lease instead of one with an annual allotment of 18000 miles  – back then I really did think that I’d have the discipline to commute in an ICE instead of an EV for 2 days/week – and the financial incentive to go back to driving an ICE every day for a month or so is compelling. So that’s what I did, sort of.

Weird thing was that during those seven days in an ICE, I did not miss the EV driving experience at all. Traffic was light, so my 2005 Mercedes C230 Sport Sedan was averaging 32 miles per gallon. Only one trip to the gas station over a 10-day period, not enough to annoy me quite yet. Twice in 10 days, that would be annoying. So I didn’t miss the convenience of “refueling” at home and work. I also didn’t long for the quietness of an electric powertrain. As I’ve mentioned in a previous blog, I actually enjoy the sound of Mercedes’ 1.8-liter supercharged 4-cylinder. Music to my ears, and I do prefer music over silence. What I did miss are the bells and whistles on the Focus Electric that are standard nowadays on any well-equipped vehicle – SiriusXM, Bluetooth connectivity, pushbutton start, navigation, touchscreen controls, and so on. The decade-old Mercedes, which seemed luxurious when I first bought it as a lease return with 38000 miles in 2009, now seems like a spartan relic from a distant past. But at 117000 miles it’s still a hoot to drive… as surprisingly awesome as the Focus Electric is in the handling department, the C230 Sport Sedan still feels more connected to the road, perhaps in part because it’s so low to the ground. In fact, it’s so low that my wife doesn’t like driving it. She says it feels like her butt is dragging on the pavement, like a go-kart.

So I was planning on commuting with the C230 exclusively until the end of this month, but that plan came to an end on Monday morning after checking out the 405 traffic on sigalert.com… it said it would take almost two hours to get to work. I hopped into the Focus Electric instead of the C230, got in the HOV lane and whizzed by no less than four fender benders, arriving at work in just over an hour.

Seems like I forgot how to drive efficiently, though, particularly in maximizing regenerative braking. In an ICE, I tend to coast more and brake later, rather than brake lightly sooner for more regen so that binders don’t have to get into the act until we’re close to a dead stop. I also tend to brake less before a turn in an ICE, letting the tires scrub off the speed rather than braking before or during the turn; it’s a habit I picked up after reading something years ago on hypermiling… if you’re going to convert energy to heat, might as well use it to change your direction faster. Why waste gas by braking before a turn and taking a few seconds longer to travel the same distance? That all changes with regenerative braking since it captures the energy and sticks it in a battery rather than converting it to heat, dissipating it to the atmosphere. So when I got back into the Focus I had to retrain myself to slow down more, and sooner, when approaching a turn, since energy lost through heat generated at the contact patch of each tire is lost forever. It took a couple of days to get used to braking earlier and lighter to achieve 99% regen on a round-trip commute.

It’s become very hard to justify keeping the C230 around. My original plan to drive it to work twice a week has failed miserably after installing those HOV lane stickers on the Focus, so the over-mileage situation on the lease will only get worse for the next two years. I started taking the C230 to used car lots to see how much cash they’d turn it into, and am currently shopping for an HOV-qualified replacement to share commuting duties with my beloved Focus Electric and to cover the occasional treks that go beyond the FFE’s range. Top of the list? A 2014 Chevy Volt.

Friday, January 10, 2014

Mating Season

Inside EVs recently ran an article asking readers which new-for-2014 plug-in excites them most: BMW i3, BMW i8, Cadillac ELR, Mercedes-Benz B-Class Electric Drive, or Tesla Model X. There didn’t seem to be much excitement expressed by many readers for any of these US debuts; any eagerness was typically  for the Model X, as one might expect. I entered a short post declaring my apathy toward the newcomers… and since I have more real estate to play with on this blog, I’ll take this opportunity to expand on that.

BMW i8, Cadillac ELR: I really don’t know much about these hybrids, except that they’re really expensive attempts at sporty coupes. If I had a good reason to buy something of that ilk, I’d opt for the new Stingray, or a fully loaded 2015 Mustang with the turbo 4, or a used Tesla roadster. In that order. My dream sports car at the moment? A plug-in Mustang for under $40K. A hopped-up Energi or BEV drivetrain will do, but I think I’d prefer the Energi drivetrain so I don’t have to tow it to the track. Take the whole trunk to convert it if necessary, no need a dedicated cargo area… after all, it is a sports car. Just leave the back seat intact so I can take my boys along for the ride.

Tesla Model X: Finally, a two and a half ton Tesla that has a good excuse for being two and a half tons, and for being among the least efficient of all BEV offerings.  Model X is to BEV as Hummer is to ICE. Don’t get me wrong, I don’t hate it. I think it’s pretty cool actually, just like the Model S. Worth every penny of its anticipated asking price. I just don’t want one. And I’m afraid my wife will eventually want one. I got her an H3 when she wanted one, and we had fun exploring its capabilities once in a while. The same would happen with the Model X. We’d get one, have fun with it for a while, and dump it when she’s bored with it and realizes how overkill it is for our daily needs. For the same amount of money, I can get her a Rav4 EV (which she is currently interested in) and use the leftover cash to get my 2014 Stingray. A red one.

BMW i3: Okay, I live in Los Angeles so I totally understand why it has to look like that – it’s an effort to win back trendy former BMW owners that defected to a Prius for its “You suck because I’m greener than you are” look – but does it have to be so dang small? It’s so small that it has less than 10 cu ft of trunk space… excusable for an ICE conversion like the Volt or Spark EV, but utterly pathetic for a design-from-scratch plug-in. The purpose-built Leaf has over double that cargo volume, and the Focus and MiEV conversions have over 30% more room back there.  And unlike most other BMWs, it bears no homage to the wonderful marque. Replace the kidneys in the front with a stylized H in an oval, and it would more convincingly pass off as a Hyundai. To me, the only BMW that's less appealing to the eye than the i3 is Griff Tannon’s converted BMW in Back to the Future Part II. BMW must have used that hovercraft as inspiration for the i3; the obvious giveaway is that orange-and-black paint scheme of i3 images that have proliferated hyped-up articles of late… same colors as Griff’s ride, just need to add some gray primer to the left rear quarter panel.

Mercedes-Benz B-Class Electric Drive: A BEV with a 100-mile range for a little over $40K… I like it, but it looks like a mini-minivan, similar to the C-Max. Not ugly; it’s actually quite pleasing. But it’s boring, to me at least, when compared to current Mercedes ICE offerings available in the US. Regardless, I think Mercedes will sell every single one they decide to build. It’s almost as long as a Leaf, so it’s much bigger than the i3, and better looking, for about the same amount of cash. But I’m wondering why they didn’t electrify the CLA instead… the CLA is an incredibly reasonably priced, beautifully sculpted version of the Mercedes A-platform that is selling like hotcakes right now. Could it be that Tesla wouldn’t share its technology with Mercedes if it were to be implemented in a sedan that would be a direct threat to their anticipated Model E?

There were a couple of other newbies not covered in the article but mentioned in reader responses – the Kia Soul EV and the VW e-Golf – that seem to line up squarely into the market currently served by the Leaf, Focus Electric, and others in terms of range, performance, and anticipated price. They will come with their own virtues and quirks,  thereby adding much-needed diversity to the current sub-$40K plug-in choices.

Perhaps there’s nothing particularly exciting about 2014 for those like me that are already committed, at least financially, to the plug-in movement. But for those just getting into the game, and for those still sitting at the bar nursing a beer, staring at the front door while waiting for perfection to make an entrance, 2014 may be the year for them. After all, more fish in the pond is a good thing.

Sunday, December 22, 2013

Free Turkeys



Back in the old days, so I was told, a year-end holiday tradition for my employer was to hand out turkeys to employees from the back of a truck. Eventually, by the time I was hired on, the tradition morphed into a gift certificate to be redeemed at a local grocery chain for a frozen bird. Perhaps not as nostalgic as a fresh-plucked hen from the tailgate of a stakebed truck (or at least that how I imagined it, loosely based on folklore passed down from the elders), but still very much appreciated. For me, that small gesture of generosity helped set the mood for a warm holiday season.

As the years passed, the privately held company was sold to a publicly traded one, then broken into pieces and sold off for a tidy profit.  Cultural practices and traditions that once set us apart from other companies gradually disappeared, including the free turkey. Layoffs, a shrinking market, and shareholders with expectations changed the climate and cadence of the workplace. Even the company-funded year-end parties have been curtailed. We had to be lean and mean. The little holiday touches that reminded me that this company cares about its employees seemed to have completely faded away… that is, until one day last week when I pulled into work. Because on that day, there were twice as many dual-port Chargepoint EVSEs than the day before. Eight EV parking spaces in total, taking up maybe a third of the first floor parking spaces that were along the west wall of the structure. It was an awesome sight. I’m not sure what was playing on SiriusXM, but it might as well have been a chorus of angels at that very moment.  That visual had way more impact on me than discovering a free turkey certificate in my company mail slot. I pulled my Focus Electric into the last available space and plugged in.

It was actually no surprise to me that the additional EVSEs were coming. Last September, after leaving a strongly worded note on a plug-in that wasn’t plugged in while parked in an EV spot,  I called the Commuter Services office for help. I reported the indecency and asked them to please put up some signage telling folks to not park there if they’re not plugged in. They gave me a phone number to call of a guy in Facilities that might be able to do something about it. So I contacted him, and it turns out he wasn’t just some worker bee like me – he is the company’s Sustainability Program Manager. I let him know of the time that I was denied a charging opportunity twice in one day at two different charging sites (each with two dual-port Chargepoint EVSEs at that time) because the last available space was taken by an unplugged EV at each site. He was very empathic about my plight, asked me for suggestions on signage (which I still owe him), and mentioned that he was planning to double the number of EVSEs by the end of the year at our location if all goes well.

The situation worsened in October and November… although the previously inconsiderate (or more likely, uninformed) EV drivers were starting to play nice, there was a very noticeable increase in the number of plug-ins at work vying for the charging spots; many times I had to wait until after 5pm to charge up. Worried that the additional Chargepoints may not come in time to satisfy the growing demand, I set up an account with EVConnect so that I can charge at a nearby Metrolink station that had a couple of EVSEs. Just in case.

Fortunately by the beginning of December, construction started to accommodate the additional EVSEs. It took a couple of weeks to complete – the foundation had to be prepped and poured for the outdoor units, and both the outdoor and garaged units had to have two metal pylons installed in front of them, in case someone pulling in forgets that the brake pedal is on the left, not the right. For a few days, the existing EVSEs in the garage were unpowered, probably in an effort to bring the new ones online. This meant that all the plug-ins were then competing for the four outdoor charging spots at a building about a mile away. I did feel bad when I beat a Volt and C-Max Energi by mere seconds to take the last available spot one Friday morning, but hey…. at least they can get home on gasoline; I needed to pump at least 9kWh of juice into my car’s battery to start my weekend. I quickly plugged in and avoided eye contact.

As promised by our trusty Sustainability Program Manager, we now have sixteen EV charging spots to serve our sites. What surprised me is that on the first morning of service in the parking garage, all eight spots were being utilized; six Volts, a Leaf, and my Focus Electric. The eight outdoor spots, probably due to a less convenient location, were only half-ultilized. Those that previously chose not to deal with the EVSE shortage are now enjoying the benefit and convenience of charging at work, and those like me who have to charge at work to get home can now rest easy that there will be a space available. To top it off, there is clear margin to serve more employees when they inevitably replace their ICE vehicles with plug-ins in the coming year.

I sent an email to our Sustainability PM, thanking him for the thoughtful holiday gift. He wrote back, excited about being able to make it happen here in California and about putting in our first EVSE at a Texas facility, with more locations to follow.

Sounds pretty wonderful to me. Perhaps this is the start of a new workplace holiday tradition.